SAAS Tools for Investor Empowerment, Listed Asset Search, Portfolio Construction & Review

Value (Fundamental) vs. Momentum: Which Investment Strategy Wins in the Long Run?

When it comes to growing wealth through the markets, investors are often caught between two schools of thought: fundamentals-based investing and momentum investing. Both approaches have loyal followers, decades of data, and moments of glory. But which one truly holds up over the long term?

Let’s unpack the core of each strategy and look at what the evidence says.

📊 What Is Fundamentals-Based Investing?

This approach focuses on the intrinsic value of a company. Investors analyze financials, growth potential, and competitive advantages to determine whether a stock is under- or over-valued. It’s the philosophy behind value investing, popularized by Warren Buffett and Benjamin Graham.

• Long-term holding periods
• Focus on valuation, financial health, and quality
• Often contrarian (buying when others are selling)
• Emphasizes margin of safety

⚡ What Is Momentum Investing?

Momentum investing centers around price trends. The belief is that assets that are rising will continue to rise (and vice versa). It relies more on market psychology and price signals than financials.

• Shorter holding periods (weeks to months)
• Focus on price movement and volume
• Uses technical analysis
• Emphasizes riding the wave

🧠 The Psychology Behind Each Strategy

Fundamental investors believe in rational analysis and long-term value. Momentum investors capitalize on short-term market behavior driven by emotion and trends.

🏁 Long-Term Performance: Who Wins?

It's not a simple winner-takes-all. Momentum strategies can outperform over 3–12 month windows, especially in bull markets. But fundamentals-based strategies tend to shine in the long run, especially through market downturns, thanks to underlying business strength.

⚖️ Risk and Volatility

• Momentum: Higher volatility, greater risk of drawdowns when trends reverse.
• Fundamentals: Lower downside risk, more resilience during market stress.

🧩 Which One Is Right for You?

It depends on your goals and temperament:

• If you're long-term focused and analytical — fundamentals-based is likely best.
• If you're agile and comfortable with short-term trading — momentum may appeal.

Some strategies now blend both — screening for strong fundamentals, then applying momentum filters for timing.

📌 Final Thoughts

There’s no single “best” strategy — but if your goal is sustainable wealth, fundamentals-based investing has a proven track record. It may not be flashy, but it’s grounded in real business performance. Momentum has its moments but often demands tighter risk management and timing.

FinSight Investment Assistant allows investors to blend fundamental and momentum strategies and monitor the success of decisions and forecasts through time.